Bay Shore Point


East River, Mathews Waterfront

186 Bay Shore Point Road
Susan, VA 23138

New CBRAR #2126302

Bay Shore Point Residence . . . This IS your perfect getaway place with room for everyone plus a separate guest cottage! Come explore the 2 story barn (with electricity), 2 car garage – room for all the toys and adventures you can dream of. Tucked at the end of the lane, surrounded by 550′ of water on a protected cove of the East River right at the mouth of the Mobjack Bay!  Fabulous fishing, water sports or just relaxing on the screened porch, build a cozy fire, or just enjoy relaxing on the swing. Pier has a 5K sling lift and a 2K jet ski lift, kayak racks, water and electricity. There are two septic systems on the property – 2BR conventional for the cottage and a new 4BR Clearstream system installed in 2011. New well in 2019 a new vapor barrier in the crawl space.


  • Acreage

    2.7 acres

  • Waterfront

    550' waterfront on East River
    off Mobjack Bay
    2-4' MLW pier
    5000 lb. sling lift
    2000 lb. jet ski lift
    Kayak racks

  • Exterior Features

    Wood siding
    Metal roof
    Screened porch
    Paver patio
    2-story barn

  • Guest House

    2 Bedrooms
    1 full bathroom

  • Garage

    Detached double


  • Built


  • Square Footage

    1587 sq. ft.

  • Foyer

    15.5 x 8.8
    Original bannister & front door

  • Three Bedrooms

    Primary -15.3 x 12.6
    Bedroom 2 - 15.3 x 13
    Bedroom 3 - 15.2 x 13.1

  • Bathrooms

    2 full

  • Kitchen

    22.2 x 13.3
    11' vaulted ceiling
    French doors to porch

  • Appliances

    Gas range
    Water purifier

  • Living Room

    15.2 x 12.6
    Electric fireplace
    Original mantle

  • Florida Room

    24,3 x 8.9
    Propane heater

  • Side Porch

    22.4 x 6.5
    Tile floor
    Laundry area

  • Screened Porch

    27.8 x 15.7
    Opens to paver patio

  • Heating/Cooling

    3-zone air/heat pump
    Window a/c units
    7 gas or electric fireplaces


Mathews County

Mathews is the second smallest county in Virginia, with 252 square miles, and has a population of approximately 9000.  In 1791, Mathews County was formed from a part of Gloucester and named for Revolutionary War General Thomas Mathews.  Well-known for its waterways, Mathews boasts 214 miles of waterfront, with much of that frontage on the Chesapeake Bay, Piankatank River, North and East Rivers, and Mobjack Bay. All this water makes Mathews a haven for boaters, kayakers, fishermen, and nature lovers.


Learn More