New Point Comfort Cottage


East River, Mathews Waterfront

4545 New Point Comfort Highway
Port Haywood, VA 23138

Sold CBRAR #2112801

New Point Comfort Cottage . . .  Own a piece of Mathews history! Waterfront cottage constructed from Williams Wharf Landing Warehouse and school buildings – moved to the site and custom crafted in 1986. So unique – reclaimed oak flooring, wainscoting and custom cabinetry crafted from solid wood doors from houses in Richmond’s Fan District.  Andersen windows and crown molding in every room. All of the bedroom closets have built-in dressers. The pier has two lifts: a jet ski lift and a 5000 lb. boat lift, a floating kayak/jet ski pier and a roller/railway option for future pier expansion. There is also a large deck and paver patio to enjoy the glorious landscaping that features camellia, azalea, hydrangea, lady slipper, lenten roses, day lilies, fig tree, iris, ferns, juniper and more! This is a turn-key sale so bring your toothbrush and start enjoying the river life!


  • Acreage

    2.6 acres

  • Waterfront

    Horn Harbor frontage
    2-4' MLW pier
    5000 lb. boat lift
    Jet ski lift

  • Exterior

    Vinyl siding
    Metal roof
    Thermal windows
    Rear screened porch


  • Built


  • Square Footage

    1508 sq. ft.

  • Foyer

    8 x 7.8
    Large closet

  • Living Room

    17.2 x 14.5
    Wood fireplace
    Custom cabinets

  • Dining Room

    19 x 12
    Opens to screened porch

  • Three Bedrooms

    11.9 x 11.5
    15.1 x 10.8
    12 x 10.9

  • Bathrooms

    2 full

  • Kitchen

    13.4 x 12
    Bar seating for 3
    Tile floor & counter
    Island & pantry

  • Appliances

    Electric range
    Washer & dryer
    Water softener

  • Heating/Cooling

    Air/heat pump
    Wood-burning fireplace
    Electric water heater


Mathews County

Mathews is the second smallest county in Virginia, with 252 square miles, and has a population of approximately 9000.  In 1791, Mathews County was formed from a part of Gloucester and named for Revolutionary War General Thomas Mathews.  Well-known for its waterways, Mathews boasts 214 miles of waterfront, with much of that frontage on the Chesapeake Bay, Piankatank River, North and East Rivers, and Mobjack Bay. All this water makes Mathews a haven for boaters, kayakers, fishermen, and nature lovers.


Learn More